Stargirl
This week we have finished the book "Stargirl" written by Jerry Spinelli.
We have read all 186/186 pages in the book. My job was to be a discussion director. I really enjoyed this job and loved leading the discussion. We talked a lot, and mostly had similar opinions. My group mates liked all of my questions and answered them with no problems. Here are my questions;
Question # 1: How did you understand when Archie said to Leo: "She is us more than we are us."? and did that lead you to thinking?
Question # 2: How do you feel about Stargirl and why do you think she left?
Question # 3: Is it worth to change your personality because of others, just like Stargirl did? Would you ever do that?
Question # 4: Do you think Stargirl was doing the right thing, making sure she did good deeds, helped everyone and would you do that if you were on her place? What is so different about her?
Question # 5: How did you like the ending of the book and did you expect it to finish out differently? Also, if you had a chance to change the ending, how would you change it?
I also recorded the answers of my group mates Marija, Anna and Katarina. (It is copy pasted from my Word Document, where I originally recorded what they said.)
1st Question.
1. Marija: She understands them more than they understand themselves.
2. Anna: She is what everyone should be like.
3. Katarina: She is the ideal person that everyone should look up to.
2nd Question.
1. Marija: I think she left because she wasn't accepted for who she was, and because she had to change herself in order to stay.
2. Anna: Nobody appreciated her and had no respect for anything good she did.
3. Katarina: She left because she wasn't accepted and didn't want Leo to feel uncomfortable
3rd Question.
1. Marija: Maybe, because if you really loved someone, you would do anything for them.
2. Anna: Maybe, because it depends on if you would change for the better or the worse. Depends on the situation.
3. Katarina: I would change depending on if it is for the good cause.
4th question.
1. Marija: I would do the same thing as she did. She is different because she is always good to everyone no matter how they react to her and doesn't want to harm anyone.
2. Anna: She is different because she is selfless. I find that as a good quality. I wouldn't feel that it is necessary to go around and take care of strangers and people that don’t know me.
3. Katarina: I find it like a good personality, and would do the same, but would have some limits. She is too kind and cares about people too much.
5th question.
1. Marija: I didn't expect Stargirl to leave, and I thought Leo would try to find her. No, I didn't like the ending. I would change the ending were Leo would go and try to find her.
2. Anna: I kind of knew Stargirl wouldn't stay and kind of expected the ending like that. The book was okay, not too interesting. I would change the ending by having Leo met her after fifteen years.
3. Katarina: No, I expected that at the end she would be accepted by the group and stayed. That is also how I would change the book. No, I didn't like the ending because I expected the ending to be a happy end.
Next week, I will be a Vocabulary En-richer for the book that we are starting to read, called Bloomability.
We have decided to read up to chapter 15, which is about 97 pages.